Recent Release | 04 Jan 2024

Economic analysis of the DOL’s proposed overtime regulation

Economic Consulting Team

Oxford Economics

THE EXEMPTION THRESHOLD

The measure the DOL has selected for this increase—a percentile of full-time southern salaries—is fundamentally arbitrary. In real (inflation-adjusted) terms, the proposed threshold ($1,158 per week) is 28% higher than the 1975 “long test” value when it was set, 40% higher than the current threshold when it was set, and only 3% below the level set in the DOL’s 2016 overtime regulation, which was invalidated by the courts. The DOL estimates that 3.4 million workers would be affected by the proposed adjustment to the EAP threshold. However, this estimate is premised on the DOL’s poorly grounded assumptions regarding the share of salaried white-collar workers who pass the duties test. If, as we suspect, the connection between salaried status and overtime exemption status is tighter than the DOL assumes, the number of affected workers could be up to approximately 7.2 million.

COSTS AND CONSEQUENCES

The DOL estimates that the 3.4 million workers that it estimates would be affected by the new rule would see their pay rise by $6 per week on average (0.6%) as a result of the proposed regulation. This represents an annualized economy-wide payroll cost of $1.3 billion. Additional non-payroll costs such as regulatory familiarization, adjustment, and managerial time bring the DOL’s total estimated annualized cost of the regulation to $2.0 billion. The DOL also identifies six additional unquantified costs of the proposed regulation and three unquantified benefits.

AUTOMATIC UPDATES

The DOL proposes to automatically update the EAP exemption threshold every three years following the implementation of the new threshold in 2024. However, the DOL’s proposed method for automatically updating the exemption threshold suffers from the same problem as its analysis of the costs of the proposed rule: a failure to model newly nonexempt affected workers losing their salaried status. Because the measure that the DOL has selected to adjust the exemption threshold (the 35th percentile of wages for full-time salaried Southern workers) is itself sensitive to which workers are paid salaried and which are paid hourly, this would result in a feedback effect where the exemption threshold is ratcheted ever higher as more workers below the new thresholds lose their salaried status.

The experts behind the research

Our economic consulting team are world leaders in quantitative economic analysis, working with clients around the globe and across sectors to build models, forecast markets and evaluate interventions using state-of-the art techniques. Lead consultants on this project were:

Dan Martin

Senior Economist, Economic Impact

Laurence Wilse-Samson

Lead Economist, Economic Impact

Recent Economic Impact reports

Zalando’s Economic Impact on the European Economy

Oxford Economics was commissioned by Zalando to produce an assessment of the company’s economic impact. The report, “The Economic Impact of Zalando in Europe” highlights Zalando's significant contributions to the European economy in 2023.

Find Out More

The Economic Impact of the British Army

This study, commissioned by the British Army, assesses both the long-term contribution the organisation makes to the UK's productive capacity and its UK economic footprint in 2023/24.

Find Out More

Economic Impact of Virgin River Season Five in British Columbia

This study, commissioned by the Motion Picture Association (MPA) – Canada, focuses on the production of the fifth season of the show "Virgin River", and analyzes its total economic impact in British Columbia in 2022. The study also considers the wider impact of the show by boosting film-induced tourism and promoting the local film industry.

Find Out More

The rise of experiences in APAC travel: an assessment of Klook’s socio-economic impact

This study highlights how Klook's innovative travel booking platform is contributing to the tourism economy in Asia Pacific.

Find Out More